I do like to try and keep an open mind; and, much as it goes against the grain to agree with anything Beaker says; I have to agree with some of the comments made. But not this one.
Unintentional depressurised argument has far too many holes in it (pardon the pun) to stand a test, almost every scenario for that can, logically, be gainsaid. The notion of an intentional act has merit and it explains the great difference between ‘crew response’ to an in flight emergency and points toward premeditation. We can argue the matter all day and still come up with little more than speculation.
It’s a fair argument; even if he is playing for the Malaysians, he is more likely to have ‘facts’ not available to the unwashed. Once again we hit the brick wall of investigation done; IMO had there been a shred of evidence to support the notion that ‘the’ pilot deliberately committed mass murder and suicide we should have known about it by now. A political ‘scandal’ is not a new thing and the arts of cover up are well practiced, it may have been headlines for a week, even caused a change in government, but it would have been a ‘full-stop’.
If, and it’s a big IF Dolan had shown himself to be, as was Caesars wife, above suspicion then that practical, logical statement would be easy to accept; for it’s a fair call. Alas, he ain’t and much of the common sense evaporates to be replaced by suspicion that Dolan is simply the glove puppet. A role he has starred in many times now, to critical acclaim.
Sound argument. Someone, somewhere knows what happened. Someone had ‘technical’ knowledge, who and why are the unanswered questions. If MH 370 is to be found, it will be found through investigation pertaining to the ‘pre departure phase’; not the after departure, in flight phase. Once airborne, the fate of MH 370 was well and truly sealed.
Quote:[for] the last part of the flight was consistent with the crew being disabled by lack of oxygen from decompression or otherwise “unresponsive”. Etc.
Unintentional depressurised argument has far too many holes in it (pardon the pun) to stand a test, almost every scenario for that can, logically, be gainsaid. The notion of an intentional act has merit and it explains the great difference between ‘crew response’ to an in flight emergency and points toward premeditation. We can argue the matter all day and still come up with little more than speculation.
Quote:“We have certainly considered that as a possibility; all the evidence we have at the moment says that is very unlikely,” he told the ABC
It’s a fair argument; even if he is playing for the Malaysians, he is more likely to have ‘facts’ not available to the unwashed. Once again we hit the brick wall of investigation done; IMO had there been a shred of evidence to support the notion that ‘the’ pilot deliberately committed mass murder and suicide we should have known about it by now. A political ‘scandal’ is not a new thing and the arts of cover up are well practiced, it may have been headlines for a week, even caused a change in government, but it would have been a ‘full-stop’.
Quote:Mr Dolan said the ATSB was concerned only with what happened to MH370 after it made its final turn south. “Speculation about who might have done what and why … is the responsibility of the Malay¬sian investigation and secondly is not important to our job, which is to find the aircraft.
If, and it’s a big IF Dolan had shown himself to be, as was Caesars wife, above suspicion then that practical, logical statement would be easy to accept; for it’s a fair call. Alas, he ain’t and much of the common sense evaporates to be replaced by suspicion that Dolan is simply the glove puppet. A role he has starred in many times now, to critical acclaim.
Quote:He said there was no need to change the priority search area to include a “rogue pilot” ¬theory because satellite tracking data indicated the plane was not subject to pilot inputs on the last long leg and was on autopilot.
Sound argument. Someone, somewhere knows what happened. Someone had ‘technical’ knowledge, who and why are the unanswered questions. If MH 370 is to be found, it will be found through investigation pertaining to the ‘pre departure phase’; not the after departure, in flight phase. Once airborne, the fate of MH 370 was well and truly sealed.
Quote:Caesar gave no evidence against Clodius at his trial, and he was acquitted. Nevertheless, Caesar divorced Pompeia, saying that "my wife ought not even to be under suspicion." This gave rise to a proverb, sometimes expressed: "Caesar's wife must be above suspicion.